Yearly Pay yearly and get 2 months free on every paid plan. See plans
Sign in Start free

Plot doctor

Input
Your plot / chapter
A young cartographer discovers that the maps she draws change the real coastline. A shipping company hires her to redraw a harbour, but she learns it will flood a fishing village. She refuses, the company steals her pens, and in the last chapter she simply draws the village back. Readers say the ending feels too easy.
Sample output Made on 27 October 2026

Plot Holes and Fixes

  1. Her power has no defined limits

    • If she can alter reality by drawing, readers will wonder why she cannot solve every problem immediately.
    • Fix: Establish strict rules: she must survey a place accurately, use rare materials, draw at a specific scale, or permanently sacrifice another stretch of coastline for every change. Revisions might also become harder once people have adapted to the altered geography.

  2. The shipping company’s plan depends too heavily on her cooperation

    • If her maps are uniquely powerful, the company should anticipate refusal and control her from the start. If her ability is not unique, stealing only her pens seems insufficient.
    • Fix: Make her the only living cartographer with this ability, and have the company initially conceal the consequences of the harbour project. Once she discovers the truth, they use contracts, legal pressure, surveillance, or hostages before resorting to theft.

  3. The pens are treated as both essential and easily replaceable

    • Stealing them should prevent her from simply drawing the village back. If ordinary tools work, the theft is meaningless.
    • Fix: Tie the power to the pens and make recovering or recreating one a major objective. Alternatively, reveal that the pens are not the source of the power—but then seed that fact early and make using another medium dangerous or costly.

  4. The company’s ability to use the stolen pens is unclear

    • If anyone can use them, why hire her? If only she can use them, why steal them?
    • Fix: Clarify that her skill determines precision, but anyone can force crude geographical changes. The company steals the pens so its own cartographer can attempt the harbour, accepting catastrophic collateral damage.

  5. The physical mechanics of redrawing the harbour are vague

    • Changing a coastline would affect tides, currents, property boundaries, ecosystems, navigation, and existing infrastructure.
Use this Plot doctor The form opens filled with this sample's inputs; change anything.